Pairing 1: Bar Dog Pinot Noir (2019) with Cabot Clothbound Cheddar Cheese
Impressions of the wine: Our first impression when smelling the wine was sort of shocking, and not in a good way, since it smelled pretty spicy and the main smell we were getting was cinnamon. The first taste was acidic, filled with spices, and did not have a lot of fruit or sweetness, so I didn't like the wine at all initially. However, after sitting open for a little while, I think the spices mellowed out and I started to get a more pleasant strawberry/cherry taste.
Impressions of the cheese: The cheese tasted very good in my opinion. It was pretty dry so it wasn't very creamy or fatty, but I did get some nuttiness, sharpness, and some saltiness.
How the two paired: When I tasted the cheddar and pinot noir together, I think the best characteristics of the cheese were brought out. I felt like the cheese had a more bold taste, and I think the wine even brought out some sweetness from the cheese that I didn't taste before. As for the wine, while it still wasn't my favorite, I think the cheese paired well with the spices of the wine, and I think the fruitiness of the wine was a nice mix with the cheese. Overall, I think if I were to have this pinot noir again, it would be with cheddar cheese or others like it. Pairs well.
Pairing 2: Fetzer Gewürztraminer (2020) with Drunken Goat Cheese
Impressions of the wine: This was my first time having gewürztraminer, and I was very impressed, since it was definitely the best wine out of the three. The first thing I noticed was that the wine was extremely fragrant, and it had a floral smell. It was on the sweeter side, which I like in my ideal wines, and the wine was light and had a crisp, refreshing taste. The flavors I got the most were peaches/apricots and apples.
Impressions of the cheese: Goat cheese is something that I've had before and enjoyed, though not nearly as much as I have had most other cheeses, so it's still sort of new to me. Since this cheese was infused with wine, I thought it tasted somewhat sweet, and I also thought that it was very creamy and had a hint of fruitiness to it. Overall I though it was a very good cheese.
How the two paired: This pairing was tough to judge, since I liked both the wine and the cheese so much that I still think the two tasted vey good together. However, I don't think this means that the two pair well together. I think that the wine was so floral, fruity, and strong that it masked the flavors of the cheese, since the cheese had extremely identifiable tastes that I did not get as much when I had it with the very flavorful wine. Does not pair well.
Pairing 3: Calvet Sauvignon Blanc (2020) with Brie Cheese
Impressions of the wine: This was my least favorite wine of the three by a relatively wide margin. When we opened and smelled the wine we all got a pretty strong ammonia-like smell and weren't really smelling anything else. We waited a bit for the smell to go away and it did not get too much better. When I tasted the wine, I got more of the same, since I got an ammonia taste along with a pear taste, and I think there was a sort of rubbing alcohol-type taste in the background. The wine wasn't very dry, and it had some mild sweetness to it.
Impressions of the cheese: I really liked the brie cheese. The cheese was very soft, so I think it was extremely creamy and had a fatty feel to it. It wasn't very salty or sweet, but the word that came to mind when I tasted it was tangy. At the start, it also had an ammonia-like smell, but it went away with time.
How the two paired: Although I did feel some similarities in the two's taste, I don't think either enhanced or took away from the other. I got basically the same taste profiles from the cheese and the wine as I did when they were separate. I also think that since the flavors were somewhat similar, the wine and the cheese did not clash with each other either. Does not pair well.